As Promised : V2 vs Intel Extreme Graphics

Started by secretfj, 12 August 2004, 11:14:14

Previous topic - Next topic

secretfj

Candidates :
1. Diamond 3D monster2 (Voodoo 2) 12MB X2 SLI
2. Intel Desktop Board D845GLAD (845GL Onboard)

Shared Components:
Pentium 4 M 1.7GHz @ 1.8GHz (150FSB X 12) <--Using Celeron D Heatsink
Intel Desktop Board D845GLAD
256MB PQI PC2100 DDRRAM @ 150MHz DDR
Seagate ST320014A

Drivers:
V2 uses Fastvoodoo 4.6
845GL uses Intel Driver 4.14.10.3732

Test:
3D Mark 2001SE build 330

The results are as follows: (IEG behaves better than V2)


Image Insert:

59.92#63728;KB
Above is the result of 845GL

Image Insert:

59.14#63728;KB
V2


Image Insert:

16.16 KB

Image Insert:

44.86 KB
Detailed (V2)

Image Insert:

21.65 KB
the 3D capabilities of V2 reported by 3D Mark

Image Insert:

16.78 KB

Image Insert:

44.56 KB
Detailed (845GL)

Image Insert:

33.14 KB
3D capabilities of IEG1 reported by 3D Mark

Image Insert:

64.18 KB

Image Insert:

51.97 KB

Something to say:
1. The original Celeron D HSF (the one with copper core) behaves very differently than the original celeron 4 HSF (my sister's C1.7). It's very NOISY....as noisy as a hair dryer
2. The preformance of IEG is quite affected by the CPU (most likely the cache). i used to use the board with a celeron 1.7, it's 3D mark result is awful (just above 1000 marks), now with a P4M, it doubled..
3. I will do the OpenGL test later, stay tuned!
No way a 3DFX collector...just a 3DFX die Hard Player~~

let the VooDoo Roars!!

P4 Extreme Edition 3.4GHz
Asus P5AD2 Deluxe i925x
2GB DDR2 667 DDRRAM
Voodoo 5 5500PCI

NitroX infinity

 

secretfj

QuoteOriginally posted by Phalanx

Which scores belong to which cards?

I've edited my original topic..to make it more readable
V2 gives 8xx marks
845GL gives 2xxx marks
No way a 3DFX collector...just a 3DFX die Hard Player~~

let the VooDoo Roars!!

P4 Extreme Edition 3.4GHz
Asus P5AD2 Deluxe i925x
2GB DDR2 667 DDRRAM
Voodoo 5 5500PCI

agrelaphon

QuoteV2 gives 8xx marks

Ain't that low for a V2 SLI + P4 ??
My V3 + P3@800 does about 13xx
 

secretfj

i dunno...
i think it's quite low too..
first i think it maybe due to limited PCI bandwidth, so i overclock and make the freq of PCI bus higher, it does perform better (from 7xx to 988), but still quite low..

i can get a thousand mark with a Celeron 1.08G and a overclocked TNT2 M64 (but all are thrown away by me now...)
maybe the next step is to get some heatsink and fans for Chips/memory, then try to overclock those V2s...



Image Insert:

129.73 KB

Image Insert:

31.28 KB

Image Insert:

124.91 KB
No way a 3DFX collector...just a 3DFX die Hard Player~~

let the VooDoo Roars!!

P4 Extreme Edition 3.4GHz
Asus P5AD2 Deluxe i925x
2GB DDR2 667 DDRRAM
Voodoo 5 5500PCI

NitroX infinity

What operating system are you using?
WindowsXP or Windows98se?
 

secretfj

QuoteOriginally posted by Phalanx

What operating system are you using?
WindowsXP or Windows98se?

oh sorry, forgotten to say, all the tests are done in Windows 98 (non-SE) English version, using DirectX 9.0B
No way a 3DFX collector...just a 3DFX die Hard Player~~

let the VooDoo Roars!!

P4 Extreme Edition 3.4GHz
Asus P5AD2 Deluxe i925x
2GB DDR2 667 DDRRAM
Voodoo 5 5500PCI